Love From Manchester, Manchester Carling Apollo (From Warrington Guardian)

Love From Manchester, Manchester Carling Apollo

IF a gig is in aid of charity, is it OK for the promoters to fall short of their promises?

Love From Manchester was truly well intended. Who could refuse the opportunity to watch some of the city's most influential artists while supporting the Asian tsunami appeal?

And with a line-up featuring Elbow and Badly Drawn Boy, it was little wonder that ticket sales alone amounted to £45,000 - all of which will no doubt help those who need it most. That said, it was the much-anticipated 'very special guests' who drew in the 2,500-strong crowd.

Doves, Ian Brown and New Order were hotly tipped/rumoured to appear, and when Peter Hook ambled up to the mic, it seemed the promise of New Order was about to come to fruition - right up until he mumbled: "Maybe next time," before scuttling away to whence he came.

Oh well, at least Tony Wilson was on hand to compere as an unknown hippy was 'hilariously' shorn of his beard (and plug his latest vested interest, Long Cut).

Please. Manchester deserved better. Bob Dylan's harmonica played in a Johnny Marr holder was about as starry as it got. Only excellent performances by the likes of Aziz and Vini Reilly of Durutti Column salvaged the night. Both were on top form as were Elbow and Damon Gough himself.

Suitable video clips and speeches by those involved first-hand with the tragedy reminded us while we were all gathered, and if my cash has helped some bereaved family for even a single moment then it was money well spent.

It's just a shame that from an entertainment point of view, Love From Manchester didn't come good on its promises.